This is a high-volatility, high-expectations story that does not need much to wobble.
A couple of insider-related headlines were enough to extend a slide, even though the underlying turnaround has been real.
So is this just a digestion phase, or the start of a deeper reset?
The Defense Plan (Sponsored)
Foreign powers are challenging the dollar while global tensions continue to rise.
Markets reward preparation, not hesitation, during moments of political and economic stress.
Savings left unprotected often take the hardest hit when volatility accelerates.
This Patriot’s Tax Shield shows how physical gold has historically helped investors protect purchasing power.
A free Wealth Protection Guide breaks down how Trump’s vision could create renewed momentum for gold.
Get the FREE guide and see how to protect savings today.
The Setup
Carvana Co (NYSE: CVNA) sells used cars online, finances a chunk of the transactions, and runs an increasingly industrial backend that looks more like a logistics and reconditioning machine than a website.
After an enormous run and a recent S&P 500 add, the stock is back in the penalty box following new filings tied to potential insider selling and a broader risk-check moment for expensive momentum names.
What Carvana Actually Does
Carvana is trying to do for used cars what e-commerce did for everything else: pull the experience online, make inventory searchable, simplify financing, and deliver to your driveway.
The unsexy part is also the important part.
The company has to source vehicles, inspect them, recondition them efficiently, price them correctly, move them through a national logistics network, and manage underwriting risk on the financing side.
That is why the ADESA integration matters so much.
The more Carvana can standardize recon work, move cars faster, and squeeze more throughput out of each facility, the more the model can scale with operating leverage.
When it works, the upside is not just more unit volume. It is better unit economics layered on top of more volume.
Trivia: According to recent surveys, what is the most common reason Americans tap into emergency savings?
Conditions Taking Shape (Sponsored)
The Fed has shifted toward easier monetary policy.
Liquidity is rising after a long period of tightening.
Institutional money continues pouring into crypto at record levels.
Crypto Revolution is a 250-page digital guide designed to help investors approach crypto strategically—without emotional trading or constant screen-watching.
Instant bonuses include a top crypto opportunity for this market environment.
Unlock full access today.
© 2026 Boardwalk Flock LLC. All Rights Reserved.
2382 Camino Vida Roble, Suite I Carlsbad, CA 92011, United States
*The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Readers acknowledge that the authors are not engaging in the rendering of legal, financial, medical, or professional advice. The reader agrees that under no circumstances Boardwalk Flock, LLC is responsible for any losses, direct or indirect, which are incurred as a result of the use of the information contained within this, including, but not limited to, errors, omissions, or inaccuracies.
*Results may not be typical and may vary from person to person. Making money trading digital currencies takes time and hard work. There are inherent risks involved with investing, including the loss of your investment. Past performance in the market is not indicative of future results. Any investment is at your own risk.
Why The Stock Is Getting Hit
The market is reacting to a familiar combo: extended valuation, a momentum unwind, and an insider headline that gives traders a reason to de-risk first and ask questions later.
The key detail is the paperwork itself. A Form 144 filing is essentially a notice of a proposed sale under Rule 144.
It does not prove shares were sold, but it can still pressure sentiment because it puts the idea of insider supply in everyone’s head at once.
Add in the timing. CVNA is heading into a macro week where rates can swing on data, and used-car affordability is extremely rate-sensitive.
The next Employment Situation report for December 2025 is scheduled for January 9, 2026, and the CPI report for December 2025 is scheduled for January 13, 2026. If either print pushes yields up, high-multiple consumer cyclicals tend to feel it immediately.
Want to make sure you never miss a stock recommendation?
Elite Trade Club now offers text alerts — so you get trending stocks and market-moving news sent straight to your phone before the bell. Email’s great. Texts are faster.
The Bull Case
1) The turnaround has showed up in real numbers
Carvana’s recent operating performance has been strong enough to justify why the market re-rated it in the first place.
Q3 2025 results highlighted major year-over-year growth in revenue and unit volume, alongside meaningful profitability metrics that would have sounded unrealistic during the stress period.
2) Scale can still unlock more operating leverage
This business is brutally fixed-cost in the places that matter: reconditioning capacity, delivery lanes, customer support, and the tech platform.
If management keeps pushing more volume through the same footprint, margins can expand faster than revenue. That is the core reason bulls stick around even after a big run.
3) The S&P 500 add can support structural demand
Inclusion can bring incremental ownership from indexers and benchmark-aware funds.
It does not change the business, but it can change the shareholder base and the marginal buyer over time. MarketWatch reported the company was set to join the S&P 500 effective December 22, 2025.
4) Unit growth plus improving economics is the dream combo
Plenty of consumer platforms can grow. Fewer can grow while also expanding profitability.
If Carvana can keep unit growth healthy while defending per-unit economics, the market will keep paying for the story, even if it periodically throws tantrums.
5) A friendlier rate backdrop would be gasoline on the fire
Used cars are one of the most financing-sensitive categories in consumer land.
If 2026 becomes a rate-cut year, or even just a rate-stability year, the affordability narrative can flip quickly. That is why those January macro prints matter so much right now.
Gap Emerging (Sponsored)
The U.S. is spending over $1 trillion on defense, and aerospace materials are in
high demand.
Titanium, critical to jets and missiles, is almost entirely imported — 91% from abroad.
One Canadian project could change the game with a massive titanium-vanadium system near shipping and power.
Surveys show magnetometer readings that maxed out the equipment, hinting at rare scale.
Could this be North America’s next major titanium source?
Few investors have noticed.
Read the full story here.
The Bear Case
1) Valuation leaves no room for mood swings
When a stock gets priced like a high-growth compounder, any sign of slowing, margin pressure, or demand wobble can trigger a sharp multiple reset.
Even excellent quarters can produce selloffs if expectations were set too high.
2) Insider headlines can become a recurring overhang
Even if Form 144 notices do not confirm completed sales, repeated filings can keep traders jumpy. The risk is not one filing.
The risk is the market deciding that the easy part of the move is over and using insider-related stock noise as a reason to de-risk.
3) Credit conditions are a silent boss fight
Carvana’s model lives and dies on the availability and pricing of funding, plus the health of the consumer.
If delinquency trends worsen or securitization markets tighten, the business can still operate, but the equity story can re-rate lower quickly.
4) Competition is not asleep
CarMax, dealers going omni-channel, and other marketplaces are still fighting for inventory and consumers. The online experience is an edge, but it is not a monopoly.
5) Execution risk compounds when you scale fast
Reconditioning throughput, logistics reliability, customer experience, and underwriting discipline all have to work at once.
When one area slips, social proof turns negative quickly, and the market tends to punish the stock before the company can show fixes in the numbers.
What I’d Watch Next
Follow-through after the insider headline: does the stock stabilize, or do rallies keep getting sold
Macro catalysts: January 9 jobs report and January 13 CPI, because rates set the tone for financed discretionary demand
Next earnings update: especially unit volume, GPU trends, and any commentary on demand elasticity
Signals from the credit stack: funding costs, access to capital markets, and any stress in consumer credit
Operational execution: recon capacity utilization and whether ADESA integration continues to improve throughput
My Take
CVNA is still the kind of name that can rip higher on good news and drop hard on vibes alone.
The business momentum is real, but the stock is priced like the market already believes the next chapter will be clean and linear. It will not be.
If you are bullish, the cleanest stance is to treat pullbacks as information.
A single Form 144 headline is not the same thing as a fundamental break, and the filing itself is not proof of a completed sale.
But if the stock cannot stabilize and the next macro prints push rates higher, this setup can turn from quick dip to longer digestion.
In other words: the bull case is alive, but it is a high-beta bull case. This is not a sleep-well position. It is a conviction-with-seatbelt position.
That’s all for today. Thank you for reading. If you have any feedback, please reply to this email.
Best Regards,
— Adam Garcia
Elite Trade Club
Click here to get our daily newsletter straight to your cell for free.
P.S. Just like this newsletter, it's 100% free*, and you can stop at any time by replying STOP.
